Full report of tribunal ruling that gave Buhari victory over Atiku, PDP

By AdvocateNews on 15/09/2019

Share on facebook Yahoo mail icon Gmail icon

Views: 751

Buhari and Atiku
Buhari and Atiku

The Presidential Election Petition Tribunal (PEPT), has released its full report, which upheld the election of President Muhammadu Buhari as the actual winner of the February 23 presidential election.

The tribunal had stated that the petitioners did not prove any of the grounds of the petition as known by law and consequently discarded the petition in its entirety.

“And the petition is hereby dismissed in its entirety,” said Justice Mohammed Garba Lawal, who delivered the judgment.

The ruling followed a petition dated March 18, by Atiku Abubakar and the People’s Democratic Party (PDP) challenging the declaration by the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), that Buhari won the election.

The tribunal dismissed part of the PDP petition that alleged that the ruling All Progressives Congress (APC) deployed security officers to manipulate the 2019 presidential election. It said that the PDP ought to have included the security officers allegedly got involved in the petition as part of the suit.

Besides, the tribunal refused the application by INEC to nullify the documents and witnesses presented by the PDP on grounds that the petitioners made wrong spelling of the lead counsel, Livy Uzoukwu’s name in their petition.

For the allegations of electoral malpractices by the petitioners, the APC and INEC urged the tribunal to strike it out, alleging it was vague and nebulous.

It decided that the allegations were vague and nebulous as claimed by the respondents even though specific areas the malpractices allegedly took place were not mentioned.

In the main allegations of none possession of minimum education qualification and submission of affidavit containing false information to INEC against Buhari, the tribunal after going through the whole hog of legal fireworks as made by the counsels, affirmed, “the second respondent (Buhari) was not only qualified but eminently qualified to contest the presidential election”.

It, therefore, dismissed the petition, saying the arguments go to no issue and was a rebuttable presumption.

The tribunal also pointed out that the evidences tendered challenging Buhari’s academic qualification were not to be relied upon since the PDP was not the maker of the certificate.

As for the controversial use of the INEC server and card reader machines, the tribunal said there was no subsisting electoral law mandating the use of smart card reader, a situation it maintained, has not changed since 2015.

It also said the card readers could only be used to administer the voter’s card and authenticate the voter but not to authenticate election results.

The five-member panel of the tribunal said the PDP’s application suggesting the use of a central server for the collation of result was, therefore, misconceived.

In part of the petition over the alleged use of a central server, the court noted that the PDP had said that Section 9 of the Electoral Act was amended in 2015.

The panel’s chairman noted: “The issue is: Can it truly be said that the section amended actually empowered INEC to transmit election results electronically?

“The court only has a duty to interpret the law. The court has no power to amend the law.”

The court read out the import of the provision, stating that Section 22 (a) does not provide for electronic transmission of results.

The court then read through other sections of the law and added that: “It is undeniable that the transmission of election result is manual at different and all levels of the elections at different stages from the states to the national level.

“There is no provision authorising the first respondent or any of its officers to transfer election results to any of the servers.

“There is also nothing allowing the first respondent to use the smart card reader for the collation of results. I’m not aware that the card reader machine has replaced the voters”.

The Certified True Copy of the judgment obtained  by politicsnigeria was signed by Sherifat Adebayo.

Posted 15/09/2019 06:21:16 AM

 

Share on facebook Yahoo mail icon Gmail icon


 

You may also like...
2019: Politicians blackmailing me over herdsmen killings –...

NCDC confirms another coronavirus case in Abuja

,Police Arrest Niger Delta Avengers Leaders

State of education in Nigeria horrifying, country in...

2019: Aspirants challenge Buhari to debate

Nigeria’s population now 198 million – NPC

Plateau killings: APC demands arrest, prosecution of perpetrators...

Police officers protest in Borno over salary arrears,...

Policeman allegedly rapes woman at ATM point

Dino Melaye: Ozekhome tells court why Senator jumped...

Boy, 18 stabs Nigerian woman to death at...

Imo Assembly removes Eze Madumere, confirms Calistus Ekenze...

 

Latest News COVID-19 kills 20 journalists in Peru UNIBEN student murder: FG orders investigation of student’s gang-rape, murder, abuse of minor Senate approves Buhari’s $5.513bn External Borrowing request 24 female victims accuse student of rape on Twitter COVID-19: Govt advises citizens of 55 and above to avoid mosques, churches Boko Haram built battle trenches in Borno community –DHQ Man sentenced to death for killing father over will COVID-19 hits 10578 cases in Nigeria FG to empower 77,400 young farmers on agric business Music legend, Majek Fashek dies Coronavirus still threatens Nigeria – Presidency warns Ikpeazu, others in isolation as commissioner dies

 

Most Read I’ve no Coronavirus, govt wants to kill me – Anambra Index case (33,679 views) Fleeing ex-DG Imo Broadcasting Corporation who stabbed wife to death arrested (25,553 views) Full Text of Governor Ifeanyi Ugwuanyi’s 2016 Budget Speech (17,163 views) Ex-Heads of State will protect Jonathan from persecution —Kukah (16,884 views) ASUU strike: Senate intervention ends in deadlock (16,022 views) All you need to know about Peter Obi, PDP VP Candidate (15,457 views) Ugwuanyi commends FG’s siting of ICT University in Enugu (14,952 views) Sickle cell support group seeks government intervention (14,018 views) Ebonyi bans embalming of corpses in homes (13,780 views) DEMOCRACY DAY: President Muhammadu Buhari’s full speech (13,073 views) France wins 2018 World Cup Final (12,468 views) The Big Kick-off: World greatest sports fiesta begins in Russia (12,411 views)

 

SECTIONS NEWS (2,670) EDITORIAL (10) POLITICS (443) SOCIETY (118) SPORTS (27) BUSINESS (305) HEALTH (38) EDUCATION (30) ENTERTAINMENT (18) INTERNATIONAL (65) TECHNOLOGY (1) COLUMNISTS (0) LETTERS (1) OPINION (21)

 

 

Julius Agwu - Crazy Interview Demands